- Thread starter
- #1
If you had to pick one of these guys to be your Franchise QB which guy are you picking and why ?
-
Welcome to Seattle Seahawks NFL Football Forum & Community!
Seahawks Huddle is one of the largest online communities for the Seattle Seahawks. You are currently viewing our community forums as a guest user.
Sign Up or
Having an account grants you additional privileges, such as creating and participating in discussions. Furthermore, we hide most of the ads once you register as a member! Furthermore, we hide most of the ads once you register as a member!
Cam Newton or Russell Wilson ?
- Thread starter Idahawk
- Start date
Wilson. All Cam did was run that flukey option attack well in a year where most defenses struggled, I assume because of the lockout. This year teams are stopping those option runs and Cam is struggling BAD. He hasn't shown he can run, or even grasp a real NFL offense.
- Thread starter
- Thread Starter
- #4
OP
No coaches , were talking about the players.
That hardly seems relevant... That just means he's big and he had one really good season in college.
SeaHawksHuddle
Huddler
Don't you know that if you are tall that means you will be an All-Pro, Super Bowl MVP QB? That's the only thing that matters in a QB.
SeaHawksHuddle
Huddler
Frankly, I picked none of the above. I would rather have Rodgers or Brady or Manning or Ryan or...
Well, duh. I think we all would rather have one of those guys.
So we are assumimg Wilson and Cam are both on the market. Let's be honest, even with the limited time in the NFL, Cam wouldn't have any trouble getting starting offers, I doubt any team would offer a starting position to Wilson, backup maybe.
It would be fun to poll all NFL coaches on that question.
It would be fun to poll all NFL coaches on that question.
With the right coaching Cam can develop into an elite QB. IMO Wilson can never be elite.
Phisically, maybe has the skills. But he isn't smart enough, and he doesn't have the intangibles. Newton's ceiling is a bigger Michael Vick.
SeaHawksHuddle
Huddler
That's a really definitive statement for something not even pros can define.
S
Seattlehawk94
Guest
$cam regressed....Last year was his "breakout year" and that's all he will ever be....Like Rick Mirer he's going to hang on for years just because "he had a good Rookie Season"...
None of the above...I'd rather have traded a few picks to have gotten RGIII...
None of the above...I'd rather have traded a few picks to have gotten RGIII...
Did you see Cam's recent press conference? Litterly called out his coaching staff, playcalling.
Not in our locker room, not thanks!!! He is a diva, I dislike Cam's million dallor smile and his over confidence, then how he shuts down in mops after looses. Those are intangibles you dont want on the battle field and the reason I like RW is he has strong character, attitude, and metal toughness.
Not in our locker room, not thanks!!! He is a diva, I dislike Cam's million dallor smile and his over confidence, then how he shuts down in mops after looses. Those are intangibles you dont want on the battle field and the reason I like RW is he has strong character, attitude, and metal toughness.
"A few picks?" More like a king's ransom... Plus it would have been inside the division.
SeaHawksHuddle
Huddler
You an RGIII fan? Odd. He seems to be too much of a runner. Didn't think you liked that in your QBs.
S
Seattlehawk94
Guest
RGIII is pass first...Like Elway actually...$cam is more like RW than RGIII..
RW is pass first too... How many rushes does he have this year? 10ish probably?
TwilightError
Huddler
I had to pick none of the above. Cam has shown no signs of progress or the needed self critique to ever be elite. Wilson has potential and he does not give up at the first failure and blame it on others, but I cant say I have seen the skill set it would require to be elite. Russell has the spirit, Newton has the physicality. If they had a baby, it might become a great quarterback. Kinda like RG3.
Similar threads
